Personal Reflection on Frances Duncan’s "When Mothers Let Us Garden"

In the quiet sanctuary of a garden, where every leaf whispers the story of patience, and the soil hums with the rhythm of timeless cycles, Frances Duncan’s When Mothers Let Us Garden invites us into a world where tenderness, growth, and humanity intertwine. This book, like the garden itself, offers a fertile space to reflect on the many layers of care, creativity, and interconnection that shape our lives. It is not merely a guide to the art of nurturing plants; rather, it is a meditation on the ways in which we, as human beings, cultivate and nourish the inner landscape of our hearts.

At the heart of Duncan’s writing is an essential truth, one that has been explored by poets, philosophers, and thinkers across the ages: the profound power of attentiveness. To tend to a garden is to step into a sacred relationship with the earth, an act that demands patience, humility, and reverence. But it also asks something deeper of us—a willingness to see beauty where it is not immediately apparent, to trust in the unseen forces that work below the surface, and to understand that growth, in both nature and life, is not always linear.

One need not look far to find echoes of this sentiment in the writings of the great thinkers who have grappled with the nature of care and creation. Rainer Maria Rilke, in his Letters to a Young Poet, speaks of the artist's role as one of quiet cultivation, a task requiring solitude and attention to the smallest of details: “Be patient toward all that is unsolved in your heart and try to love the questions themselves,” he writes. In this, we sense a kinship between the gardener and the poet, both of whom seek to create meaning from the soil of their inner worlds.

Frances Duncan’s book invites us into that very same space of quiet contemplation. In the pages of When Mothers Let Us Garden, we are not simply shown how to tend to flowers and vegetables; we are also encouraged to tend to the garden of the self. There is an underlying message that caring for a garden is akin to caring for one’s own soul—a task that requires moments of stillness, gentleness, and a deep connection to the world around us.

The title itself, When Mothers Let Us Garden, hints at a delicate interplay between nurturing and freedom. The act of gardening, particularly when encouraged by a mother figure, is not just an external activity but a symbolic gesture of permission and trust. Duncan understands that, just as a mother might gently guide her child’s hand while planting a seed, so too must we learn to guide ourselves with gentleness and patience. It is this same tenderness that makes the process of growth possible—whether in a garden, in relationships, or within the hidden recesses of our hearts.

In many ways, this gentle care resonates with the words of the poet and philosopher John O'Donohue, whose reflections on beauty and belonging remind us that the most transformative moments in life often arise from the simplest of acts. He writes, “The beauty you see in the world, the beauty you receive in your life, comes from a place deep within you, from a home you were born to long before you came into this world.” It is this invitation to return to a place of inner richness that Duncan extends through her writing. The garden becomes a metaphor for a homecoming—not just to nature but to ourselves.

To garden is to be in a constant dance with time, a dance that neither resists nor hastens the inevitable cycles of life. The growth of a plant mirrors the growth of the soul; it is an unfolding that requires a commitment to the present moment, without rushing to the future or dwelling too long in the past. It is this mindfulness that Duncan captures so beautifully throughout her work. As the poet W. H. Auden once wrote, “Time will pass, and seasons will change, and gardens will grow,” yet the beauty lies not in the future of these things but in their quiet unfolding.

Duncan’s words carry the weight of these timeless truths with a quiet grace. She draws us into an awareness of the simple yet profound rhythms of life—the rhythms that pulse through the roots of the plants in a garden, through the hearts of the people who tend them, and through the quiet spaces of our own minds. It is an invitation to slow down and to honor the spaces between the moments, where the most significant transformations often take place. As the philosopher Simone Weil once observed, “Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity,” and in the garden, we are asked to offer this attention not only to the plants but to the unfolding beauty of the world itself.

When Mothers Let Us Garden also acknowledges the vulnerability that comes with creation. Gardening, like all forms of art, carries the risk of failure. The plants may not grow as expected, or the weather may be unkind. Yet, there is a beauty in this unpredictability. For it is in the willingness to embrace failure that we learn the truest lessons about growth—lessons about resilience, about surrender, and about the quiet strength that arises when we allow ourselves to be fully present with the uncertainty of life.

In this sense, the garden is not merely a space for cultivating plants but a sanctuary for cultivating grace. It is where we learn to accept what comes, to nurture what grows, and to release what no longer serves us. It is in this act of release that we find true freedom, for only when we let go of our attachments to outcomes can we allow ourselves to be open to the quiet miracles that unfold in their own time.

Duncan’s book resonates with the quiet wisdom of the ancients, from the contemplative silence of the Tao Te Ching to the tender kindness of the Buddha’s teachings. The great spiritual traditions have long recognized the value of simplicity and presence. The garden, as Duncan so beautifully illustrates, is a space where we can access this simplicity—a space where, through the act of creation, we come to understand that we are not separate from the world around us but an integral part of it. As the philosopher Martin Heidegger wrote, “The more we come to understand our place within nature, the more deeply we are connected to it.”

It is this very connection that Duncan celebrates in her writing. For in the garden, we are reminded of our interdependence—not just with the earth but with one another. Each seed that is planted, each bud that blooms, is a reminder that we are not isolated beings but part of a larger, ever-evolving story. This interconnectedness, so beautifully illustrated through the act of gardening, invites us to reflect on how our actions, our choices, and our attentiveness ripple out into the world, touching lives in ways both seen and unseen.

In the end, When Mothers Let Us Garden is not merely a book about cultivating plants. It is a book about cultivating life—about creating spaces where beauty can grow, where relationships can deepen, and where the soul can find its place within the great tapestry of being. Duncan’s work is an invitation to step into the garden, to embrace the simple act of tending, and to discover in the process a deeper connection to ourselves and the world we inhabit.

Through her gentle, philosophical prose, Duncan offers us a path back to our most authentic selves, a path illuminated by the quiet light of care, attention, and the steady rhythm of growth. And in doing so, she invites us into the most sacred of all gardens—the one that blooms within our own hearts, where love, creativity, and humanity are always waiting to be nurtured.

All my Love and Light,
An

Image: Amazon